Speaking of Justice…

Posted By on May 27, 2004 at 11:07 pm

I hope the previous post made it clear: I am all in favor of extremely harsh sentencing for “cyber criminals,” by which I mean “those who would damage or destroy our information infrastructure, and those who would use it to cause harm to people or organizations” (not “androids sent from the future to kill Sarah Connor.”)
At long last, via James Joyner, we find a plan that makes sense:

If we execute murderers, why don’t we execute the people who write computer worms? It would probably be a better investment.

Hear, hear.
Write a virus, maliciously crack a server, defraud people via e-mail, initiate a denial-of-service attack, spam thousands or millions of mailboxes… it’s all the same to me.

I’d take a big tall tree and a short piece of rope
I’d hang ’em up high and let ’em swing ’til the sun goes down

(Charlie Daniels, “Simple Man“)
Once upon a time, hanging was a reasonable and prudent punishment for all manner of crimes. We’ve become more lenient over the years; I don’t see how it’s helped.

Not Enough Justice

Posted By on May 27, 2004 at 10:17 pm

The Justice system can work – though not as efficiently or as effectively as we might hope:

BUFFALO, N.Y. – A man who sent 850 million junk e-mails through accounts he opened with stolen identities was sentenced to up to seven years in prison on Thursday.
Atlanta-based Internet service provider Earthlink Inc. said it hoped the sentence and an earlier $16.4 million civil judgment against Howard Carmack will deter other spammers.
“Before spammers send one more spam e-mail, we think they should remember that what happened to Howard Carmack can happen to them,” said Karen Casion, Earthlink’s assistant general counsel.

Unfortunately, this was mere human Justice.
Had it been a true act of Cosmic Justice, Carmack would have been flattened by a Hormel truck on his way to the courthouse.